The Rule in One Line
An IRA can hold silver bullion that's at least 99.9% pure, made by a national mint or an approved refiner, and held by the IRA's custodian at an approved depository. Most collectible coins and older 90% silver coins don't qualify.
Commonly IRA-Eligible Silver
| Product | Issuer | Purity |
|---|---|---|
| American Silver Eagle | U.S. Mint | 99.9% |
| Canadian Silver Maple Leaf | Royal Canadian Mint | 99.99% |
| Austrian Silver Philharmonic | Austrian Mint | 99.9% |
| Australian Silver Kookaburra | Perth Mint | 99.9% |
| British Silver Britannia (newer issues) | Royal Mint | 99.9% |
| Silver bars and rounds | Approved refiners | 99.9%+ |
Eligibility can depend on the year and version. Ask your custodian to confirm before you buy.
Silver That Doesn't Qualify
| Product | Why Not |
|---|---|
| Pre-1965 U.S. dimes, quarters, half dollars ("junk silver") | 90% silver |
| Older British Britannias | 95.8% silver |
| Most graded, proof, or "rare" silver coins | Treated as collectibles |
| Sterling silver items | 92.5% silver; collectibles |
Gold vs Silver Purity Rules
| Gold | Silver | |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum fineness | 99.5% | 99.9% |
| Statutory coin exception | American Gold Eagle (91.67%) | American Silver Eagle (meets 99.9% anyway) |
| Common bars | 1 oz, 10 oz, 1 kilo | 10 oz, 100 oz, 1 kilo |
| Most common disqualifier | 91.67% coins like Krugerrands | 90% pre-1965 coins |
Who Makes IRA-Eligible Silver Bars?
Bars generally need to come from a national government mint or a refiner accredited by a recognized exchange or market body, such as those approved for regulated futures delivery. Well-known refiners and mints, including the Royal Canadian Mint, PAMP, and Valcambi, produce bars that custodians routinely accept. Ask your dealer for the refiner name and confirm it with your custodian before buying.
Storage and Weight
Silver is far bulkier than gold for the same value. When the gold-to-silver price ratio is around 80, a given dollar amount of silver weighs about 80 times as much as the same dollar amount of gold. That's why some depositories price silver storage differently. Ask whether your storage fee is based on value, weight, or a flat rate.
Taking Silver Out of Your IRA
You can take a distribution as cash (the metal is sold) or in kind (the silver is shipped to you). In-kind distributions are taxed at fair market value on the distribution date for traditional IRAs. Because individual silver coins are worth relatively little, silver makes it easy to take small in-kind distributions, which some people find handy for required minimum distributions.
Coins vs Bars for Silver
Silver coins are easy to recognize and sell a few at a time, but their premium is often a large share of the metal's value. Larger bars (10 oz, 100 oz) usually cost less per ounce but are less flexible when you take distributions. A mix of both is common.
Typical Premium Over Spot (Illustrative Ranking)
General ranking only; actual premiums vary by dealer and market conditions. Ask for written quotes.
Pricing Traps With Silver
- Proof and limited-mintage coins can carry premiums far above standard bullion.
- "Free silver" bonuses are often paid for through higher prices elsewhere in the order. See free silver promotions explained.
- Price per coin vs per ounce: always compare per ounce.
Augusta's "free silver" report details how these offers work.
Where to Buy IRA-Approved Silver
Augusta Precious Metals offers silver IRAs alongside gold, with a stance against premium-heavy products; reported $50,000 minimum. Noble Gold sells silver plus gold, platinum, and palladium; reported $20,000 minimum. See best silver IRA companies, and compare with IRS-approved gold.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Silver Eagles IRA-Eligible?
Yes. American Silver Eagles are 99.9% silver and IRA-eligible.
Can I Put Junk Silver in an IRA?
No. Pre-1965 90% silver coins don't meet the purity rule.
Can I Move Silver I Already Own Into an IRA?
No. The IRA must purchase metals with its own cash.
Are Silver Rounds Allowed?
Rounds from approved refiners at 99.9% purity can qualify. Confirm with your custodian.
Are Silver Maple Leafs IRA-Approved?
Yes. Canadian Silver Maple Leafs are 99.99% silver and IRA-eligible.
Do Silver Proof Coins Qualify?
Some U.S. Mint proof Silver Eagles may be allowed, but they carry higher premiums. Most other proof and graded coins don't qualify.
How Much Does Silver IRA Storage Cost?
Often similar to gold, around $100 to $150 a year, but some depositories charge more for silver because of its bulk.
Get the Free Silver IRA Kit
See which silver fits your IRA and how to avoid overpaying.
Get Your Free Gold IRA Kit